Manga tracking: spreadsheet vs Notion vs dedicated app

Updated

Short answer: use a spreadsheet if you enjoy building your own system, Notion if you want your collection alongside other notes, and a dedicated app if you’d rather spend your time on manga than on maintaining a tracker. Here’s how they compare in practice.

Full disclosure: we make ReadLedger, a dedicated app, so we’ve tried to be fair and to say where the other options are genuinely better.

SpreadsheetNotion templateDedicated app
SetupBuild it yourself, or use a templateDuplicate a template, then learn itSign up or install
Adding a seriesType every rowAdd entries by hand, depending on the templateUsually search by title
CoversRarely worth the effortAdd them manuallyUsually automatic
Checking on a phoneFiddly at larger sizesWorkable, can be slow on big databasesDesigned for it
Stats and chartsBuild your ownLimited to what the template offersBuilt in
CustomizationUnlimitedHighLimited to the app’s features
CostFreeOften free, some paid templatesVaries by app

Spreadsheets: most control, most upkeep

Nothing beats a spreadsheet for tracking something unusual, such as print run or signed copies, because you just add a column. Your data also stays in a simple format that will outlast any app. The downside is that you are the developer: typing every volume, fixing formulas, and making charts. Phone use is the usual breaking point.

If that sounds right for you, start from our free spreadsheet template.

Notion: good if you already live there

Notion templates look great and can link your collection to reading notes and reviews. They make the most sense if you already use Notion daily. Without that habit, you’re learning a whole productivity tool to keep a list. You’ll also generally enter volumes by hand, and getting stats beyond what the template provides takes some work with formulas.

Dedicated apps: least effort, least flexibility

A dedicated app handles the tedious part. You search for a title, volumes and covers appear, and stats build up on their own. In exchange, you can only track what the app supports, and you depend on it staying available. That makes export important: before you commit to any app, check that you can get your data back out. Some apps also limit free accounts or run on only one platform.

We compare specific options, including pricing and platforms, in the best manga collection tracker apps.

Which should you choose?

  • Under 50 volumes, and you enjoy tinkering: a spreadsheet is plenty.
  • You keep notes and reviews on what you read: Notion.
  • You buy in shops, or want spending stats without any setup: a dedicated app.

You can also switch later. ReadLedger imports CSV files, so a spreadsheet is a safe place to start.

Keep reading